Unraveling the Truth about Alpaca Fleece

Written by Veronica Kassatly

I am grateful for the help of Jaanus Vosu (perualpaca2010@gmail.com), Walter Antezana, and Mauricio Nunez Oporto.

Hand spinning, Jaanus Vosu, 02/02/22

After silk, alpaca is the second most vilified fiber in the sustainable apparel industry. Alpacas are camelids — long-necked herbivores that thrive in dry and hostile environments. Not surprisingly, as with sheep for the Navajo, and silkworms in India and China, the wonder of a creature that can turn inedible vegetation, often in an inhospitable landscape, into food and clothing, has endowed alpacas with mystical status amongst the indigenous peoples of the Andes. The Alpaqueros – alpaca farmers – of the Andesdon’t divide man and animals, our animals also have feelings. To them, alpacas are children, siblings, parents, and to them, we are the guilty party: “the western world taught us to separate the elements of nature, when it is a matter of seeing the ecosystem as a unified whole“.

In a series of 3 articles, we examine the history and significance of alpaca farming in Peru and unravel the truth about who benefits from characterizing alpaca farming as environmentally harmful. 

Part 1: Alpaca – More Prized Than Gold by the Incas, Still Scorned by the West?

In Part 1, we take a close look at what alpaca are, why they are so well-suited to the Peruvian altiplano, where sustenance is scarce and the indigenous inhabitants have few options, and we price check alpaca against other fibers – it’s expensive. As discussed in my previous articles on silk, this means that there is an economic incentive for brands and their funded initiatives to portray alpaca as environmentally harmful. Do they? And if so, is it justified?


Part 2: Fibs, Lies, and Falsehood 

In Part 2, we examine how alpaca fiber ranks in terms of environmental impact using the Higg Materials Sustainability Index (MSI) and the Kering Environmental Profit & Loss (EP&L) account. We look at the shortcomings of these measurement tools in assessing alpacas’ cultural, social, and economic value to indigenous peoples. Finally, we dig into the competing interests in the mining industry for land use in Peru.


Part 3: When PETA Strikes, Certifications Follow

In the third and final article, we take a closer look at the claims for alpaca made by the ‘sustainable’ apparel sector. I walk through how these claims prioritize a global north perspective that diminishes the most disadvantaged, those in the global south who are producing the fiber. We conclude with an understanding of how the claims of ‘environmental harm’ are contributing actual harm to the livelihoods of small-scale alpaca farmers.


Share this Story:

3 thoughts on “Unraveling the Truth about Alpaca Fleece

  1. I weep for humanity and the planet. Our current take and discard system of capitalism has destroyed what it touches. I am glad that fibershed is working to get the word out but the magnified megaphone of industry continues to spin twisted tales meant to be deceiving. They’re pushing polyester? Fossil fuel based fake fiber that is accumulating in the oceans depths.
    Seriously how can aware people turn this tide?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Get The Latest Updates

Never Miss a Story

Join our email community to get the latest updates from Fibershed, from the fiber to the farm. 

The Latest from Fibershed

Recent Fibershed Stories

Plastics White Paper

Download Our New White Paper!

In this free resource, we’ll reveal how plastic solidified its place as one of the most prominent materials in fashion, we’ll talk about what that means for all of us, and we’ll share some of the best solutions for getting us out of this mess.